Problems & Puzzles:
Puzzles
Puzzle 81.- Sophie Germain
primes - magic squares
A very natural extension of the Puzzle
80 is to ask for couples of magic squares such that the corresponding
cells contain couples of Sophie Germain primes.
For the magic squares 3x3, here are what I think are
the smallest examples, that I have found:
Couple of Magic
Squares 3x3, Sophie Germain 1st order
| 106121 |
179 |
55733 |
|
212243 |
359 |
111467 |
| 3623 |
54011 |
104399 |
2p+1 |
7247 |
108023 |
208799 |
| 52289 |
107843 |
1901 |
|
104579 |
215687 |
3803 |
Couple of
Magic Squares 3x3, Sophie Germain 2nd order
| 8521 |
727 |
5479 |
|
17041 |
1453 |
10957 |
| 1867 |
4909 |
7951 |
2p-1 |
3733 |
9817 |
15901 |
| 4339 |
9091 |
1297 |
|
8677 |
18181 |
2593 |
Questions:
a) Can you find smaller examples of
these 3x3 Magic Squares?
b) Can you find examples of these kind of Magic Squares for higher orders:
4x4, 5x5, ..., etcetera?
c)
Can you find the least triplet of 3x3 magic
squares with SG primes p, 2p+1, 4p+3 (1st order) or p, 2p-1, 4p-3 (2nd
order)?
Solution
Felice Russo has found smaller examples of SG 3x3
squares 1st and 2nd order:
1st Order
1481 1889 2063
2963 3779 4127
2393 1811 1229 4787 3623 2459
1559 1733 2141 3119 3467 4283
2nd Order:
3391 3697 7639 6781
7393 15277
9157 4909 661 18313 9817
1321
2179 6121 6427 4357 12241 12853
4339 1867 8521 8677 3733 17041
9091 4909 727 18181 9817 1453
1297 7951 5479 2593 15901 10957
***
I have received (8/3/2000) by snail-mail a 4x4 prime
magic square Sophie-Germain 1st order type, sent by John E. Everett, form
Waynesboro, VA:
| 23 |
719 |
1229 |
1031 |
|
47 |
1439 |
2459 |
2063 |
| 1049 |
1019 |
281 |
653 |
|
2099 |
2039 |
563 |
1307 |
| 491 |
251 |
1451 |
809 |
2P+1 |
983 |
503 |
2903 |
1619 |
| 1439 |
1013 |
41 |
509 |
|
2879 |
2027 |
83 |
1019 |
He has sent also some ideas for other puzzles with
prime-magic squares that soon I'll post in future puzzles pages.
***
John E. Everett sent (24/03/2000) the following
4x4 prime SG 2nd order type:
(the lower one)
| 139 |
2179 |
4339 |
547 |
| 499 |
3319 |
1759 |
1627 |
| 3067 |
1399 |
727 |
2011 |
| 3499 |
307 |
379 |
3019 |
***
|